Phileas Frogg: The side with better PPP is always more militarily dangerous than the side with better GDP. We’re going to learn that hard lesson very soon, but what do you expect? We’re ruled by bankers and merchants, while Russia and China are ruled by spies and engineers. The first country to fully re-embrace rule by warriors is going to be hellacious to deal with for a few years.
Bob Sykes: The novels of Jane Austin, Charles Dickens, and Thomas Hardy, truly excellent as stories, also provide detailed descriptions of life in Britain during the 19th Century. Austin for the gentry, Dickens for the urban poor, and Hardy for the rural working class. Also, A.J.P. Taylor’s history of WWI has an analysis of the economic conditions in the run up to the War, and he concludes that working class was materially better off under wartime rationing than during the peace in the early 1900’s. The...
Jim: Traditionalists think that education should prioritize acquiring knowledge, that it should focus on ‘hard’ subjects like science, mathematics, and foreign languages, and that it should take place in a highly structured environment, where students’ time and behavior are tightly regulated. Progressives think that education should prioritize acquiring skills, that it should embrace ‘soft’ subjects beyond the supposed academic core, and that students should be given wide freedom in which to develop...
Steve Sailer: Characters in 19th Century novels are constantly “overworking” ; and then taking off a summer or an entire year from their jobs. That doesn’t happen that much anymore. It’s a little hard to grasp what that was about.
Dan Kurt: “Hely Hutchinson Almond, headmaster of Loretto School, who described his school’s priorities as ‘First – character, second…’” A late professor of modern history told me that the German military from the reforms in the early 19th century until its defeat in WW2 tried to select its officers under the chief criterion of one’s Character.
Bruce: “Does it ever occur to you that maybe all these idiots are lying?” — Ed Real, whom I trust on education stuff, maybe about someone else.
Bruce: “Alas, before Wolper could put his plan into action, the book began drawing criticism from Native American groups contending that it was an inaccurate portrayal of the Sioux.” Crab-bucket jealousy has ruined publishing for books about anything with an organized political entitlement class. Even writers of the right ethnicity get taken down if they are any good, like William Sanders.
Jim: And as for myself, I suspect that hard labor would do the lawyers, accountants, software developers, VC executives, bureaucrats, clergy, politicians, and so on a lot of good.
Jim: Capitalism is often described as a celebration of selfishness. That description misses its most extraordinary feature: a functioning market economy is a system of cooperation among strangers. Nearly every object in a modern household exists because thousands of people coordinated their activities. They may live on different continents, speak different languages, practice different religions, and disagree on nearly every political question. They need not love one another! They need only identify a...
Jim: The Constitution of the United States of America was simply a contract of a bloodline. That constitution then withered and died, in irregular increments, in proportion to the supplantation of that bloodline, in its own territory, by the global power which has, since approximately 1830, been shuffling around races en masse, beginning with the Irish Catholics dispatched to Boston, the seat of the American Revolution. Such is life.
Bob Sykes: The Enlightenment died around 1800, and it was replaced, after a while, by Romanticism. The various socialist movements of the 19th and 20th Centuries are the main product of Romanticism, along with Beethoven, Shelley, Nietzsche, Spengler, Hitler… Romanticism, itself, is pretty much dead, too, and has been replaced by Modernism, then post-Modernism. America’s Founding Fathers and their ideas are long dead, and so is the Republic they gave us. We couldn’t keep it. Their Constitution has been...
Wanweilin: Human existence, for thousands of years, has generally been nasty, brutish and short. Only in the last couple of centuries or so has this reality improved. Now as Christendom fades from Western Civilization we are returning to the average human experience. Electricity and water are already intermittent in many areas. Then the intelligent fraction that knows the how and why will die. Then only a few will remain to maintain an ever collapsing infrastructure. Look what happened in Africa when the...
Bruce: A biological attack on America would see the D party using masses of drug-addicted vagrants to shake down the taxpayers as a Godsend.
Jim: The logic of court eunuchry explains far, far too much of America c. 2026.
Phileas Frogg: Jim, Absolutely. The state’s willingness to employ coercive measures, even non-violent coercive measures, to achieve ends well beyond their prescribed scope should shock everyone with a conscience or self-respect. But then, they don’t want their court eunuch’s to have self respect, so all the better.
Jim: You know, compulsory and quasi-compulsory schooling is also a form of hostage-taking.
Not Fauci: Antibiotics work quite well. Panic only drives voter turnout to increase government power ‘for your safety’.
Bob Sykes: Hirsch is badly misinformed and confused. The function of the Ivies, and most modern “elite” schools, is not education but networking. They are the places where the children of the Ruling Class meet each other and begin to form alliances, or at least a common set of goals. The Medieval royal courts did the same job for the nobility, although the basic reason noble children were schooled and fostered at the royal courts was hostage taking to ensure against noble rebellions.
Jim: Is America actually worthy of this sort of knob-slobbering? Is the United State?
Bill: Even further back, in the 19th century, sodbusting American pioneers faced mental challenges in the plains: “Prairie madness or prairie fever was an affliction that affected European settlers in the Great Plains during their migration to, and settlement of, the Canadian Prairies and the Western United States in the 19th century. Settlers moving from urbanized or relatively settled areas in the East faced the risk of mental breakdown caused by the harsh living conditions and the extreme levels...
