Isocaloric but not Isometabolic

Wednesday, April 13th, 2011

Equal amounts of glucose and fructose may be isocaloric but not isometabolic:

This means we can eat 100 calories of glucose (from a potato or bread or other starch) or 100 calories of sugar (half glucose and half fructose), and they will be metabolized differently and have a different effect on the body. The calories are the same, but the metabolic consequences are quite different.

The fructose component of sugar and H.F.C.S. is metabolized primarily by the liver, while the glucose from sugar and starches is metabolized by every cell in the body. Consuming sugar (fructose and glucose) means more work for the liver than if you consumed the same number of calories of starch (glucose). And if you take that sugar in liquid form — soda or fruit juices — the fructose and glucose will hit the liver more quickly than if you consume them, say, in an apple (or several apples, to get what researchers would call the equivalent dose of sugar). The speed with which the liver has to do its work will also affect how it metabolizes the fructose and glucose.

In animals, or at least in laboratory rats and mice, it’s clear that if the fructose hits the liver in sufficient quantity and with sufficient speed, the liver will convert much of it to fat. This apparently induces a condition known as insulin resistance, which is now considered the fundamental problem in obesity, and the underlying defect in heart disease and in the type of diabetes, type 2, that is common to obese and overweight individuals. It might also be the underlying defect in many cancers.

If what happens in laboratory rodents also happens in humans, and if we are eating enough sugar to make it happen, then we are in trouble.

Comments

  1. Ross says:

    Anyone interested in this topic will be well-rewarded by watching Dr. Robert Lustig’s talk “The Bitter Truth”. Covers it all, from biochem, to social policy.

  2. Foxmarks says:

    I used to believe Taubes was full of crap. A calorie is a calorie.

    But the body is not a simple thermodynamic equation. I tried a version of the paleo diet, with no added sugar. It feels great. And the sugar I do eat tastes sweeter.

  3. Isegoria says:

    I thought I’d watched and linked to Lustig’s talk before, but I hadn’t.

Leave a Reply