States have never been formed by elections

Tuesday, January 12th, 2010

States have never been formed by elections, Robert Kaplan notes:

Geography, settlement patterns, the rise of literate bourgeoisie, and, tragically, ethnic cleansing have formed states. Greece, for instance, is a stable democracy partly because earlier in the century it carried out a relatively benign form of ethnic cleansing — in the form of refugee transfers — which created a monoethnic society. Nonetheless, it took several decades of economic development for Greece finally to put its coups behind it.

Democracy often weakens states by necessitating ineffectual compromises and fragile coalition governments in societies where bureaucratic institutions never functioned well to begin with. Because democracy neither forms states nor strengthens them initially, multi-party systems are best suited to nations that already have efficient bureaucracies and a middle class that pays income tax, and where primary issues such as borders and power-sharing have already been resolved, leaving politicians free to bicker about the budget and other secondary matters.

From Was Democracy Just a Moment? (1997).

Leave a Reply