Regulatory arbitrage, pure and simple

Friday, October 10th, 2008

Arnold Kling examines an FDIC document on the risk weights of different bank assets, and finds that securitization dominated the mortgage market because of regulatory arbitrage, pure and simple:

The higher the weight, the more capital the bank has to hold against that asset. As I read table 1 and table 3, if you originate a loan with a down payment of 20 to 40 percent, the risk weight is 35. But if you buy a AA-rated security, the risk weight is only 20. So if a junk mortgage originator can pool loans with down payments of less than 5 percent, carve them into tranches, and get a rating agency to rate some of the tranches as AA or higher, it can make those more attractive to a bank than originating a relatively safe loan.

Leave a Reply