According to Human Lie Detectors Almost Never Miss, a small fraction of the population possesses a remarkable talent for spotting lies:
As he lies, the young man shrugs, flutters his eyelids and shakes his head. Another, on a witness stand, grimaces for a millisecond as he answers a question.Most people believe they could easily detect such lying behavior, but in fact most miss a good 50 percent of lies, says deception expert Maureen O’Sullivan of the University of California San Francisco.
But O’Sullivan says she has found a special group — just 1 percent of those she has tested — who catch a lie nearly 90 percent of the time.
“We call them wizards,” O’Sullivan told a briefing sponsored by the American Medical Association on Thursday. “Wizardry is a special skill that seems magical if you don’t have it.”
These wizards have a special ability to ferret out little tics that show when a person is lying.
She and her colleagues have so far screened 13,000 people for their ability to catch a liar on videotape. “We found 14 people who we called ultimate experts,” she said.
They could tell when people deliberately lied about feelings, committing a crime or their own opinions.
Another 13 were good at detecting specific types of lies. For example, she said, “There was a group of cops who got very good scores — they got 80 percent or more on crime but none of them did well on the video about feeling.”
I have to ask a few statistical questions. First — and most trivially — how do 14 “ultimate experts” and 13 more specialized lie-detectors add up to 1% of the 13,000 people they’ve tested?
Second, if a normal person spots a lie 50% of the time, then 1% of those normal people will spot lies far more than 50% of the time, just by luck. (And another 1% of those normal people will spot lies far less than 50% of the time, just by back luck.) In fact, with a 50% chance of catching any particular lie, there’s a 1% chance of catching nine lies out of ten. (Of course, there’s roughly zero chance of catching 90 lies out of 100, if, in fact, you have a 50% chance of catching each lie.)