Best Buy is like an arms dealer

Sunday, August 5th, 2018

Best Buy should be dead, but it’s thriving in the Age of Amazon:

There is, of course, one thing Best Buy has that Amazon doesn’t: more than 1,000 big-box stores. Joly saw the benefit of using them as showrooms — a word so fraught in retail that the company calls them showcases — for the big tech brands, Amazon included. Best Buy was among the first chains to feature Apple boutiques. In April 2013, Joly said there would be Samsung mini-shops in its 1,400 U.S. locations by June. That same month, Best Buy began adding 600 Microsoft stores-within-stores. Sony arrived in 2014. Last year, Best Buy turned over more space to Amazon and Google to better display their smart home technologies. The two are bitter rivals: Amazon doesn’t sell Google Home and offers a limited selection of Google’s Nest products. Best Buy is neutral ground.

The brands essentially pay rent to Best Buy (it’s cheaper than building stores) and either send in their own salespeople or train the blue shirts. No one at Best Buy would offer details about these partnerships. But even analyst Michael Pachter of Wedbush Securities Inc., who in almost 10 years has never recommended buying Best Buy’s stock, describes the partnerships as a phenomenal success because they ease the financial burden of operating stores while enhancing profit margins. “Best Buy is like an arms dealer,” he says. “They’re indifferent to what brand you buy as long as you buy it from them.”

[...]

In August 2013, the company recruited Rob Bass from Target Corp. to make it more efficient and to save a couple hundred million dollars to help cover the costs of Joly’s price-matching strategy. Bass discovered quickly why customers were frustrated: Best Buy’s distribution centers typically weren’t open on weekends or holidays, and its warehouse management software was at least two decades old. The software has been updated, the supply operations extended, and two-day free delivery is standard on orders of $35 or more. In April 2016, Best Buy announced it would offer same-day delivery in a few cities for a fee. Right after that, Amazon expanded same-day delivery to some Prime customers for free. Best Buy then lowered its price, which had been as high as $20, to $5.99. This past holiday season, Best Buy expanded its same-day service to 40 cities.

Bass also turned back to the stores. He started a system that allowed them to fulfill orders via delivery and pickup. Best Buy says 70 percent of Americans live within 15 miles of one of its locations, so it’s been encouraging customers to come collect their orders. Forty percent of the time they do, which “helps my budget a lot,” Bass says. To make those pickups faster, the company is testing an “On My Way” function on its app to ensure customers don’t arrive before their TVs are retrieved from the back of the store. Since 2012 the proportion of its online revenue has more than doubled, from 7 percent of all U.S. sales to 16 percent, well above those at other big-box retailers.

As individual pieces of technology become simpler to use, connecting them gets more complicated and important for their utility. To Joly, this was a missed opportunity. “The vision I had from the beginning is for us to be to the consumer what a company like Accenture is for a business,” he says.

To one longtime employee, this was an enticing idea: an elite group of salespeople who could offer more than the Geek Squad did. Corie Barry had tried to start an advisory program in 2010 when she was a senior director without a budget. Now she’s chief financial officer.

Comments

  1. Jello Beyonce says:

    Dig a little deeper, BestBuy and Amazon share one important trait:

    The largest institutional shareholders of BestBuy (BBY) include:
    Vanguard
    Fidelity
    State Street
    BlackRock
    JP Morgan
    Geode
    Northern Trust
    And other of the largest money-management firms, whom operate collaboratively, forming virtual monopolies amongst the largest corporations in every single industry.

    http://investors.morningstar.com/ownership/shareholders-major.html?t=BBY

    The largest institutional shareholders of Amazon (AMZN) include:
    Vanguard
    Fidelity
    State Street
    BlackRock
    JP Morgan
    Geode
    Northern Trust
    And other of the largest money-management firms, whom operate collaboratively, forming virtual monopolies amongst the largest corporations in every single industry.

    http://investors.morningstar.com/ownership/shareholders-major.html?t=AMZN

    By owning such large swaths of shares (often 40 percent or more), these large institutional shareholders wield tremendous control over corporate Boards, Executive Management, and thus operations, policies, etc.

    Take a look at many supposed “competing” corporations, like Apple. Alphabet, Amazon, Microsoft, IBM, Kroger, WalMart, Whole Foods (via Amazon), the largest defense contractors, the largest banks, the largest insurance companies, the largest pharmaceutical companies, etc., you’ll see the same largest institutional investors again and again.

    This is all part of the new American “planned market economy”, that is, “capitalism” only for a select few, the new-feudal Lords.

    An article titled “Institutional Investors and Their Impact on Company Growth” by Gijs van de Wetering highlights this well.

    “By having such a large position, institutional investors (e.g. pension funds, hedge funds, life insurance companies, etcetera) play a significant role in multiple aspects of the economy as a whole and in financial markets.”

    “Institutional investors….have a more specialised knowledge to select the right firms and more power to monitor the managers correctly.”

    “Chen et al. (2007) have shown that true long-term focused institutions exert more effort on monitoring than on investing.”

    In fact, many of these institutional shareholders provide management consulting, ensuring their held corporations comply with standard operational procedures.

    Further, “institutional investors hold[ing] a large portion of a firm’s shares, which they cannot sell easily without the risk of lowering the share price too much.”

    Thus, these large institutional shareholders, aside from actively managing business operations and management, provide return value to that business by providing stability of share pricing, even rising stock pricing (via supply/demand).

  2. Rollory says:

    I took a Win7 computer in to the local Best Buy to have a fan replaced. They changed all my OS and desktop settings, set the computer to auto-install Win10 in the middle of the night, uninstalled my virus protection, installed several pieces of software of their own, and did not touch the fan.

    I no longer do business with Best Buy for any reason.

  3. Harry Jones says:

    I go into a Best Buy from time to time. It’s been a long while since I bought from them. They just never seem to have what I want.

    And the salespeople seem hungry. Also, apologetic.

Leave a Reply